Saturday, October 15, 2011

Nicola Benedetti plays Brahms and Beethoven

I spend a recent weekend in Termonfechin, a sleepy village in Louth, where twice a year a whole slew of people go to play chamber music. I was playing Brahms (the third piano quartet). Our violinist was amazed that I didn't know of Nicola Benedetti, though I discovered she hadn't heard Alina Ibragimova or Amandine Beyer, so everyone came away with something to discover.

I think I had been put off Nicola Benedetti by the pouffy-lipped publicity photos that you see everywhere, making her look like a soviet supermodel. I have been listening to her playing, though, and have to admit that once again I let myself be fooled by the idiots in the publicity department.

It's a sweet, warm sound and a wonderful way of responding to the music that is close to the singer's art. People often think of cantabile as meaning seamless playing, but when you listen to singers you realise that the vowels are separated and shaped by consonants – tiny breaks that convey much of the meaning. Listen to her playing and you'll see what I mean. It's more about the attack and release of the notes than the beautiful tone in the centre.

And to decorate this posting, I've managed to find a great photo that shows Benedetti as a real, actual person, with a very ordinary Alexei Grynyuk slouching at the piano beside her. It's when the playing starts that you are suddenly aware of the magic.

And as a postscript, I have to add that I smiled when I heard the Brahms. Miriam, the violinist who recommended Benedetti to me, plays just like that though with, for me, a slightly darker vision. Thanks Miriam!

Beethoven: Violin Sonata No. 7 in C minor Op. 30 No. 2
Brahms: Violin Sonata No. 1 in G major Op. 78

Nicola Benedetti, Alexei Grynyuk (Piano)
Wigmore Hall, 10 Oct 2011

m4a 320kbs VBR

Download from Rapidshare


  1. >> I have been listening to her playing, though, and have to admit that once again I let myself be fooled by the idiots in the publicity department.<<

    That makes two of us. Will have to hear Benedetti now. Thanks!

  2. Hi! Great blog. I've just added you to my favorite blog's list.

    Check please my new blog about contemporary music, which can be of your interest:

    If you like it, ¿could you add it, please, to your favorite blog's list?


  3. Boom – it's difficult, isn't it, for a woman to be taken seriously as a musician by the major labels. Look at the ridiculous job they did on Anna Vinnitskaya, for heaven's sake! A woman who looks wonderfully slavic, powerful and intelligent, adorning her first CD cover made up to look like something that escaped from the research labs in Laboratoire Garnier.

    plof – welcome!

  4. Well, line me up with those who forgot that Benedetti - unlike most of the media-driven "superstars" of music (K Jenkins, R Watson, you know the sort) - actually started by winning the BBC prize, which you don't get for looks. (Though your 'soviet supermodel' phrase perfectly sums up the CD covers - - I shall hang onto that one!)

    This is good Beethoven. Thank you!